In the digital age, your creativity and efficiency are often only as good as the tools you’re using. A question that haunts many creative professionals is which iPad stylus to choose: Apple Pencil 1st Gen or 2nd Gen? You might be surprised at how far this seemingly minor decision can take you.
In this article, we will unravel the mystery surrounding the pros and cons of Apple Pencil 1 vs 2 and provide guidance on how to make the best decision specifically tailored to your needs. Buckle up, and let’s dive into the world of Apple Pencils.
When choosing between Apple Pencil 1 and 2, it’s crucial to consider the device you’ll be using. Not all iPads are compatible with both versions of the Apple Pencil, and some iPads perform better with specific versions.
If you’re unsure about which iPad to get, our article on getting the best iPad for Procreate offers a detailed breakdown of the top options available, helping you choose the perfect match for your Apple Pencil.
Understanding the Core Differences Between Apple Pencil 1 vs 2
Haptic Feedback – A Game Changer
One significant feature that sets the Apple Pencil 2 apart is the implementation of haptic feedback. This exclusive feature enhances the tactile experience while drawing and writing, providing a more authentic, pen-and-paper feel.
The first-gen Pencil, while advanced for its time, lacks this feature. Haptic feedback might not be crucial for everyone, but for artists who value immersion, it’s definitely a game changer.
Wireless Charging – A Convenience Worth Considering
The Apple Pencil 1st gen needs to be plugged into the iPad or charged with an adapter, which can be cumbersome and aesthetically unpleasing.
Apple Pencil 2nd gen, however, charges wirelessly on the side of the iPad Pro. This reduces clutter and makes for a more seamless experience. If you prioritize a clutter-free work environment, the 2nd gen Pencil might be your preferred choice.
Design – A New Grip on Creativity
Apple Pencil 1 has a cylindrical, glossy design that makes it prone to rolling off of flat surfaces. The 2nd gen Pencil sports a matte finish and a flattened edge that ensures it won’t roll away.
Moreover, the flattened edge provides a comfortable grip, allowing for extended periods of use without hand fatigue. The redesigned Apple Pencil 2 is aimed at offering you greater control and precision.
Tap Gesture – Enhanced Functionality at Your Fingertips
The Apple Pencil 2 comes with a new feature called the double-tap gesture. By simply double-tapping the lower section of the Pencil, you can switch between tools or invoke customized shortcuts, streamlining the creative process.
Unfortunately, Apple Pencil 1st gen users will miss out on this added functionality.
Pressure, Tilt Sensitivity, and Latency
The Apple Pencil has been widely celebrated for emulating the intricacy and tactile nuances of traditional art tools. Two aspects that capture the essence of this technology are pressure and tilt sensitivity, which are present in both Apple Pencil 1 and 2. Additionally, let’s explore latency and how it affects your overall experience.
Pressure Sensitivity – A Detail-Oriented Approach
An essential element to consider is pressure sensitivity. Fortunately, both Apple Pencil versions offer the same level of sensitivity, boasting 4096 pressure levels. This feature provides precise control, allowing smooth transitions between lines and shades, thereby increasing the realism of your artistic endeavors.
Tilt Sensitivity – Perfectly Emulating Traditional Art Tools
Tilt sensitivity is another crucial aspect. As an artist, adjusting stroke width by tilting the stylus can make a significant difference in your work. Apple Pencil 1 and 2 both include this advanced feature, ensuring a natural creative experience that closely mirrors the nuances of using traditional tools like pencil or brushes.
Latency – A Smooth, Seamless Sketching Experience
Latency is the time it takes for your iPad to register your input, and minimizing this lag is essential for a seamless drawing experience. Apple Pencil 1 and 2 both boast remarkably low latency. However, newer iPad Pro models paired with the Apple Pencil 2 may achieve even lower latency levels, resulting in an even smoother, near-instantaneous response.
Apple Pencil Compatibility
Apple Pencil (2nd generation)
You can use Apple Pencil (2nd generation) with these iPad models:
- iPad mini (6th generation)
- iPad Air (4th generation and later)
- iPad Pro 12.9-inch (3rd generation and later)
- iPad Pro 11-inch (1st generation and later)
Apple Pencil (1st generation)
You can use Apple Pencil (1st generation) with these iPad models:
- iPad mini (5th generation)
- iPad (6th, 7th, 8th, and 9th generation)
- iPad (10th generation)*
- iPad Air (3rd generation)
- iPad Pro 12.9-inch (1st and 2nd generation)
- iPad Pro 10.5-inch
- iPad Pro 9.7-inch
* You need the USB-C to Apple Pencil Adapter to pair and charge Apple Pencil with iPad (10th generation).
Software and App Compatibility
The Apple Pencil has become a staple for many artists, students, and professionals alike. But how do the different Apple Pencil models fare when it comes to software and app compatibility? Let’s explore the world of apps and which one works best with the original Apple Pencil and its successor.
Seamless Integration Across Devices: Apple Pencil 1 vs 2
When it comes to app compatibility, both Apple Pencil models seamlessly integrate across a wide range of apps. Whether you’re a professional artist or an avid note-taker, you’ll find that the majority of apps work flawlessly with both the original Apple Pencil and the newer model.
Software developers recognize the importance of supporting these popular styluses, ensuring that your iPad and Apple Pencil interact harmoniously across numerous applications.
Apple’s Native Apps: The Ultimate Creative Suite
Apple’s native apps, such as the Notes, Pages, and Keynote apps, take full advantage of the capabilities of both Apple Pencil models, allowing you to write or sketch directly within these applications.
Popular Third-Party Apps: A World of Possibilities
Many widely-used third-party apps are designed with Apple Pencil functionality in mind. Renowned drawing apps like Procreate, Adobe Fresco, and Autodesk Sketchbook offer a complete toolkit to enhance the creative process, while productivity apps like Notability, GoodNotes, and Microsoft OneNote make the most of the stylus’s precision for note-taking, highlighting, and annotating.
Rest assured that whether you choose the original Apple Pencil or its refined successor, you won’t be held back by limited app compatibility.
Customization and Gestures
While the core functionality of Apple Pencil 1 and 2 remains largely the same in most apps, Apple Pencil 2 users can take advantage of the double-tap gesture for switching tools or invoking custom shortcuts in several apps.
This added functionality can make a difference for those who value efficiency and effective tool management.
To Sum Up
Both Apple Pencil models excel in the realm of software and app compatibility, ensuring that you get a smooth experience regardless of your choice. It boils down to the iPad model you own and the features each stylus offers. So, whether you opt for the original Apple Pencil or the newer Apple Pencil 2, your creativity is in good hands.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q. Can I use Apple Pencil 1 on an iPad Pro that supports Apple Pencil 2?
A. No, you cannot use Apple Pencil 1 on an iPad Pro that supports Apple Pencil 2, as they have different connectivity and charging methods.
Q. Can I use Apple Pencil 2 on a non-Pro iPad model?
A. No, Apple Pencil 2 is only compatible with the 11-inch and 12.9-inch iPad Pro models from 2018 onwards.
Q. Is there a significant difference in pressure sensitivity between Apple Pencil 1 and 2?
A. Both versions have the same level of pressure sensitivity, offering 4096 levels to provide precise control and fluidity in your creative workflow.
Q. Do Apple Pencil 1 and 2 work on iPhone or Mac?
A. No, Apple Pencils are designed only for specific iPad models and are not compatible with iPhones or Macs.
Q. Is there a notable price difference between Apple Pencil 1 and 2?
A. Yes, Apple Pencil 2 is usually more expensive than Apple Pencil 1, due to its upgraded features and enhanced design.
Q. How long does the Apple Pencil’s battery last?
A. Both Apple Pencil versions provide up to 12 hours of nonstop usage (mixed use) or 24 hours in standby mode.
Q. Do third-party apps work with Apple Pencil 1 and 2?
A. Yes, many third-party apps provide support for both Apple Pencil 1 and 2, such as Procreate, Notability, and GoodNotes.
Q. Can I still buy the Apple Pencil 1st gen from the Apple Store?
A. As of writing, Apple Pencil 1 is still sold on the Apple Store and other online retailers, alongside the 2nd gen model.
Q. Can I replace the Apple Pencil nib if it becomes worn out or damaged?
A. Yes, you can easily replace a worn-out or damaged nib with Apple’s official replacement nibs or compatible third-party options.
Q. Is there a specific screen protector that works best with the Apple Pencil?
A. A matte screen protector is often recommended for an authentic pen-and-paper feel while using the Apple Pencil. There are many options on the market, catering to your specific preferences.
Q. Which One Is Better? Which One Should You Use?
A. The better choice between Apple Pencil 1 and 2 depends on your specific needs, preferences, and the iPad model you are using.
Each has its unique features, but in terms of the core functionalities, such as pressure sensitivity and compatibility with apps, both perform similarly. Evaluate the pros and cons, and decide which stylus best meets your requirements.
Q. Can the Apple pencil 1 or 2 be used on the iPhone?
A. No, neither Apple Pencil 1 nor 2 can be used on iPhones. They are designed exclusively for use with iPads and are not compatible with other devices.
Q. Is the Apple Pencil 2 or 1 better for Drawing?
A. Both Apple Pencil 1 and 2 provide a smooth experience for drawing, as they share similar pressure sensitivity and tilt recognition.
However, Apple Pencil 2 offers added features like double-tap gesture and improved design, which may enhance the overall drawing experience for some users.
Q. How to Charge Apple Pencil 1?
A. To charge Apple Pencil 1, plug the Lightning connector at the end of the Pencil into the Lightning port of your iPad. Alternatively, you can use the included Lightning adapter to connect the Pencil to a Lightning cable for charging.
Q. Is one better than the other for taking notes?
A. Both Apple Pencil 1 and 2 offer a similar experience for note-taking. However, the Apple Pencil 2 features an improved design (with a less slippery grip), and double-tap gesture, which might be advantageous for some users when taking notes.
Q. How many Apple Pencils are there?
A. Currently, there are two Apple Pencil models – Apple Pencil 1 (first generation) and Apple Pencil 2 (second generation). These models are distinguished by various features, compatibility, and design elements as discussed earlier in this article.
Analyzing the differences between Apple Pencil 1 vs 2, it’s evident that they cater to different user preferences and requirements. Despite sharing some core functionalities, their unique features make each stand out in their right.
Ultimately, the decision rests on the model of iPad you own and the features you prioritize. Whatever choice you make, you can be confident that both Apple Pencils can boost your productivity and creative potential.
Other related articles: